Review process

The Editorial Board of Vojenské reflexie reviews all articles and their compliance with the requirements and mission of the journal. The approved articles are send for out for assessment by two reviewers.

The process is based on the „double-blind peer review“ system, which means, that both the reviewer and author identities are concealed from the reviewers, and vice versa. Care is taken to ensure that the reviewer and author are not from the same institution.

The Peer Review Feedback Form includes detailed assessment of the article and its individual parts, the justification of the opinion, and conclusion of the assessment. The conclusion states whether the article is recommended for publication in its original version, or whether it should be rewritten or amended according to the reviewer´s recommendations (or sent for re-assessment) or rejected.

The authors of the articles are informed about these facts by the Chairman or the Secretary of the Editorial Board,

Peer Review Feedback Form

     Review form (.rtf 149 kB)